You already seem decided on a PS3, but the only reason I'd recommend the Xbox 360 would be for the online experience. But seeing as you don't care about that, definitely get a PS3. I've learned that Xbox 360s are apparently very cheaply made and tend to break after a certain period of time. I've gone through two of them in the span of about four years. Ugh. If I didn't already have a crapload of 360 games, I'd switch to the PS3 myself.